Book Review: Mr Dickens and His Carol by Samantha Silva

Mr Dickens and His CarolAbout the Book

Charles Dickens should be looking forward to Christmas.

But when his latest book, Martin Chuzzlewit, is a flop, his publishers give him an ultimatum. Either he writes a Christmas book in a month or they will call in his debts and he could lose everything. Dickens has no choice but to grudgingly accept…


Format: eBook (244 pp.), Hardcover (320 pp.) Publisher: Allison & Busby
Published: 31st October 2017                               Genre: Historical Fiction

Purchase Links* ǀ ǀ Barnes & Noble
*links provided for convenience, not as part of any affiliate programme

Find Mr Dickens and His Carol on Goodreads

My Review

For you, does Christmas not really start until you’ve read the words, ‘Marley was dead, to begin with’? Is for you the perfect wet, overcast Christmas afternoon spent watching your favourite adaptation of the ultimate feel good Christmas story (whether that’s starring Alastair Sim, Albert Finney, my own personal favourite Patrick Stewart …or even The Muppets)? Have you ever found yourself taking a second glance at a door knocker on a murky night because you fancy it has changed shape? Do the words, ‘I see a vacant seat…in the poor chimney-corner, and a crutch without an owner’ reduce you to a helpless blubbering wreck? If you can answer yes to any of those questions, then Samantha Silva’s Mr Dickens and His Carol is the book for you. It’s a full-on love letter to one of Charles Dickens’ most famous and best-loved books: A Christmas Carol.

It’s 1843 and Charles Dickens finds himself in the peculiar situation of no longer experiencing the literary success to which he has been accustomed.   Furthermore, he’s in danger of being overshadowed in the literary firmament by authors such as Thackeray. On top of all that, he’s weighed down by the financial burden of supporting his growing family, well-appointed house, impecunious family members and all manner of social causes. What’s more, Christmas is approaching when his purse seems to have ever increasing demands upon it.

When his publishers insist that he write a Christmas book (and do it the space of a few weeks), Dickens is initially appalled at the idea that he should write in response to public demand. “Well! From now on I should simply ask my public what it is they’d like to read.” When Dickens does eventually resign himself to the commission, he finds himself suffering an extreme case of writer’s block. I’m sure many authors will empathise with his efforts to overcome it.

When morning rounded the bend for noon, and the tempest outside blustered on, Dickens had a clipped conversation with The Master’s Cat (who offered no useful ideas at all), took three stretching breaks, a light lunch and a cold bath to clear his head. By late afternoon he had one half-written paragraph that was illegible for all the scratching-out, and barely good enough for the bin.’

A chance encounter during one of Dickens’ customary night-time perambulations through London finally brings inspiration. However, when the muse finally strikes will it be the A Christmas Carol we are familiar with or will Dickens first need to go on his own journey into his past, present and future?

The author really captures the atmosphere of Dickens in the descriptions of London. ‘The clusters of tenements and rows of lodging-houses looked cramped and unhappy, with dwarf doors and squeezed windows, broken shutters, if shutters at all, and more paper and rags than glass in them. There was a barber in one front parlour, a herring vendor in another, a cobbler visible through an opening out back.  A few rickety balconies leant hard on thin wood columns, like crutches, and threatened to drop at any moment.’

I loved spotting the passing references to A Christmas Carol dotted throughout the book – names, phrases or snippets of dialogue. I laughed out loud when the author made Dickens utter the phrase ‘Humbugs? Bah!’ and again when Dickens was allowed to indulge in the ultimate literary revenge towards a hapless autograph hunter.

The Dickens who emerges in this book is a family man, a loving if at times somewhat neglectful husband, a supporter of social causes, loyal friend and generous host. Clearly, there were other sides to his character. For instance, he would later very publicly separate from Catherine, his wife of twenty-two years, after becoming enamoured with a young actress. If you would like to explore this further, consider my ‘try something similar’ recommendation below which, on this occasion, is not very similar at all.

However, if you love A Christmas Carol or even (whisper) if you don’t but know someone who does, then Mr Dickens and His Carol would make the perfect Christmas gift.   Being in the former category, I absolutely loved it and I couldn’t imagine anything nicer than unwrapping the book with its gorgeous cover on Christmas morning.

I received an advance reader copy courtesy of publishers Allison & Busby in return for an honest and unbiased review.

Follow my blog with Bloglovin

In three words: Charming, funny, uplifting

Try something similar…Catherine Dickens: Outside the Magic Circle by Heera Datta (click here for my review)

Samantha SilvaAbout the Author

Samantha Silva is a writer and screenwriter based in Idaho. Mr Dickens and His Carol is her debut novel. Over her career she’s sold projects to Paramount, Universal, New Line Cinema, and TNT. A film adaptation of her short story, The Big Burn, won the 1 Potato Short Screenplay Competition at the 2017 Sun Valley Film Festival. Silva will direct, her first time at the helm. A graduate of Johns Hopkins University’s School of Advanced International Studies, she’s lived in London, Bologna, and Rome, is an avid Italophile and a forever Dickens devotee

Connect with Samantha

Website ǀ Goodreads




14 thoughts on “Book Review: Mr Dickens and His Carol by Samantha Silva

    1. Hope you love it as much as I did. Best consumed with mince pies, a slice of Christmas cake and glass of port or other tipple I think. My husband told me off for keep reading out bits of it because he wants to read it too.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. A Christmas Carol is one of my favourite Christmas traditions – I read it every year, we watch it every Christmas Eve (we’re an Alastair Sim household), and this year I’m taking my dad to a live version. Needless to say, this is going on my December TBR this year.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, that’s a great version as well, especially as it has another fabulous actor, Michael Hordern, playing Marley’s ghost. I saw a one man version on the stage once, by British actor Clive Francis, and it was wonderful. Hope you enjoy the book if you read it. I’m told there’s a film out as well -The Man Who Invented Christmas – about Dickens writing A Christmas Carol.

      Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.